Jailbreaking iPhones – What’s at stake?

1 11 2012

by Adam Rauf

Chances are, if you’re a smartphone owner in the year 2012, you most likely are carrying either an iPhone or an Android device.  If you’re an iPhone user, you’re probably quite happy with your device; after all, it can run a lot of applications, make phone calls, and send text messages, amongst other features.  However, your Android brethren often will chastise you for having such a “locked down” device, considering rooting an Android has slowly become a very easy task over the years.  Granted, there are a lot of concerns in having a device that is rooted (or jailbroken), but the ability to overclock, tether, and generally do what you wish with your handset is a privilege that is not as easily bestowed to iPhone users.

A quick Google search for “jailbreak iphone” will lead to a Wikipedia article about “Privilege Escalation.”  To the common user, what is that exactly?  Privilege Escalation is “the act of exploiting a bug, design flaw, or configuration oversight in an operating system or software application used to gain elevated access to resources that are normally protected from an application or user[1].”  So in essence, jailbreaking allows the user to exploit some sort of bug in the operating system so that they can gain full access to their handheld device.  In the case of Android devices, people would install custom roms, new basebands and versions of the OS, or as stated previously, be able to tether or overclock their phones.  In the case of the iPhone, users may be less tempted to want to install custom roms, but being able to overclock, tether, and upgrade baseband radios for better signal are certainly neat advantages that bedroom hackers may be interested in.  Now, keep this in mind, it’s still an exploitation of the operating system.

Jailbreaking does come at a price.  Back in 2009, 21-year old Australian student Ashley Towns wrote the first “iPhone virus [2].”  Jailbreaking software available at the time installed an SSH service on their phone.  And if users did not change their default password [“alpine”], they could be hit with this version of this virus, which would change their wallpaper and play Rick Astley’s single, “Never Gonna Give you Up[2].”  So while this was no more than an annoyance at the time, Towns proved that as easy as it was to jailbreak your device, you also had to worry about now changing your SSH passwords, which many users could possibly neglect.  As the saying goes, “with great power comes great responsibility.”

This same bug was exploited just weeks later, but with more malicious intent.  Security company F-Secure pointed out that users in the Netherlands were being targeted, particularly in their banking logins [3].  While Towns may have been trying to bring awareness to this security hole as a Whitehat, this was clearly more of a malicious intent, basically treating the iPhones as a botnet, with a command & control post, and could propagate to more phones via unsecured wifi, for example [3].

Of course, Apple being the walled garden that it is, saw serious issues with this idea of jailbreaking.  Not only did it create new vulnerabilities, but the stability of the device was now compromised.  No longer could people have the device that “just works.”  Perhaps for the same reason that they build all of their machines to certain specs, the last thing the company wanted was for devices such as the iPhone and iPad as well as the iPod to be hacked.  For quite some time, they saw this as copyright violation.  However, in 2010, the DMCA (Digital Millenium Copyright Act) that Apple used as its legal muscles gave way to jailbreaking.  The copyright office found jailbreaking to not infringe on any rights and granted an exemption to it [4].  As much noise as Apple made about it, they had lost this battle.  So now, it was no longer illegal to jailbreak your phone, but much like Android handset carriers, they did warn you that it would void your warranty.

To also deal with the “walled garden” effect of Apple and provide a means to get apps, the Cydia app was developed.  Users can go to JailbreakMe.com on their device and quickly jailbreak their phone [5].  They also made it quickly reversible, so that you can go back to iTunes and restore your device [5].  There is however, no guarantee that you can’t brick your device, or cause some sort of damage to it.  And because Cydia is overlooked by a team of users not specifically working at Apple, you can’t always trust what apps you can download, and there’s no rigorous testing process; you’re basically going in somewhat blind into territory that’s unchartered.  None of the apps are going to be signed by any authority, and there’s nothing stopping a user from flooding the market.  Does that sound scary to any of you yet?

Apple has gone to great lengths to brand and image themselves as a secure vendor.  Their slogan of “It just works,” amongst their hip campaigns is supposed to imply that you won’t be dealing with all of the viruses/malware of Windows.  But, we’re starting to see phishing attacks on users.  Myself and friends included have gotten text messages leading to nefarious URLs.  And since some of us are on Android or jailbroken iOS devices, we can sideload apps.  What’s to say we haven’t downloaded something insecure?  Apple may say you don’t need an antivirus, but the mobile space is still relatively new to us and it may come back to bite us later.  For example, is there any way we could detect if we’re being DNS cache poisoned, or if people are intercepting our data when we sign into wifi?

Let’s fast-forward to the future, where we currently still have no cracks into the iPhone 5.  The iPhone 5 runs iOS 6, and has yet to be broken.  In fact, as early as today, October 9th, the jailbreak team working on it has disbanded [6].

Okay, so now we all have some background on what jailbreaking is, and where we are with it.  The questions I pose to you, the readers, is what incentives do we see with jailbreaking these days?  Is it purely to stiff the man and have full access to the device, or is it no longer important due to the malware and vulnerabilities that are propagating in the mobile space [and thus requiring users to install anti-virus and anti-malware apps]?  Does the fact that jailbreaking is now easier somehow make Android less attractive, considering how easy [*chuckle*] it was to root Android phones previously to get the same kind of performance from iOS?

If I may throw my hat in the ring, I tend to think jailbreaking was once a huge part of the “nerdy” culture, much like how people would choose to run Linux over Windows or Mac.  You might not do anything really amazing with it, but you got some “cool points” from peers for jailbreaking/rooting your device and throwing customized UIs and applications over top of it.  But then again, much like Linux, it was the privileged few that could afford to get iPhones or Android devices in the beginning.  But now, as we start to see devices drop to the cost of pennies, you’re a small part of a large majority.  You’re not really running a whole different OS than everyone; you’re running something modded.  And while that still might be “cool,” that hip appeal is slowly starting to fade.

Recently, the US Navy also showed how the mobile space is getting to be a scarier place.  The recently released “Placeraider” malware they developed would silently use your camera function to take pictures while you are unaware, upload the photos to one of their servers, and map out a 3D image of your surroundings [7].  This is absolutely frightening; rooting or not, security has become a bigger issue, and will continue to become an issue as we move forward.  It also emphasizes the importance of users being more diligent as to what permissions they grant applications when they install them, especially when this program asked for no more rights than your common photo app like Instagram [7].

I currently own a Samsung Galaxy Nexus [the Apple lawsuit is another story].  I’m running the latest Google OS of Jellybean.  I didn’t have to root my device like I rooted my original Motorola Droid to get a lot of the features I got on this device.  I no longer need to overclock, I no longer have an issues with tethering, and I’m able to sideload apps if I wish.  Is the appeal for rooting there for me?  Not really.  Unless I want to spend time bragging to friends, there’s not a whole lot I would like to change about my phone.  And with Apple devices, we’re starting to see the same thing.

Are users interested in voiding their warranties, downloading apps from possibly untrusted/untested sources, and opening themselves up to exploits outside of Apple?  Probably not.  While Apple does make mistakes, they do have a responsibility to their users to patch vulnerabilities.  In the Android world, there certainly are people who help take the sourcecode from the Google Devs and morph it into custom roms that may patch vulnerabilities that aren’t even patched with the official OS.  While that can still be true with Apple devices, the certainly do cost more, and definitely more to replace.  So the “fun factor” of jailbreaking your device may not stack up against the “cost factor” of having to replace the device.

______________

1. “Privilege Escalation.”  Wikipedia, The Free Encyclopedia.  Wikimedia Foundation, Inc.  4 October 2012.  Web.  <http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Privilege_escalation&gt;

2. Andersen, Brigid.  “Australian Admits Creating First iPhone Virus”  ABC News AU.  10 November 2009.  Web.  <http://www.abc.net.au/news/2009-11-09/australian-admits-creating-first-iphone-virus/1135474&gt;

3. “New iPhone worm can act like botnet say experts.”  BBC News.  23 November 2009.  Web.  <http://news.bbc.co.uk/2/hi/technology/8373739.stm&gt;

4. “Exemption to Prohibition on Circumvention of Copyright Protection Systems for Access Control Technologies.”  Copyright.gov.  Web.  Revised 24 August 2012.  <http://www.copyright.gov/1201/&gt;

5. Comex, Grant Paul, Jay Freeman (saurik), MuscleNerd, et al.  “JailBreakMe.”  JailBreakMe.  Web.  <http://www.jailbreakme.com/&gt;

6. Harbison, Cammy.  “iOS 6 Untethered Jailbreak Team Splits As New Alliances Are Formed, Still Promising Results.”  International Digital Times.  9 October 2012.  Web.  <http://www.idigitaltimes.com/articles/11677/20121009/ios-6-untethered-jailbreak-team-splits-new.htm&gt;

7. McLellan, Heather.  “US Navy Helps Create Camera-Hijacking Smartphone Malware.”  The Escapist.  1 October 2012.  Web.  <http://www.escapistmagazine.com/news/view/119890-US-Navy-Helps-Create-Camera-Hijacking-Smartphone-Malware&gt;

Advertisements

Actions

Information

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out / Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out / Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out / Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out / Change )

Connecting to %s




%d bloggers like this: